The Murder of Alexandra Anaya

August 13, 2005, 13-year-old Alexandra Anya disappeared from her home. Her torso was found 3 days later floating in a river. Who murdered Alexandra Anaya?

13 year old Alexandra Anaya was murdered in 2005 | Momma Loves True Crime

August 13, 2005

Alex's mother, Sandra, last saw her daughter in the very that early morning at the family's home on Pine Avenue. When she left the home that morning while Alex was eating White Castle. However, when she returned home Alex was gone. Sandra was only gone for a few hours. When she came home, Alex was gone. She was reported missing the same day.

The family now had to wait.

August 16, 2005

Boaters, on the Little Calumet River in Chicago, found the torso of a female. The torso was wrapped in chains. The discovery made the news. 

Lieutenant Ron Johnson was assigned to Alexandra's case. When he saw the news, he called Chicago police immediately. Now, DNA testing would need to take place to determine if this was her.

During this time period, Sandra Anaya went to a police department in Chicago. She was providing DNA for testing.

Despite this, there was no way this was her daughter. She did not even entertain that notion.

Three weeks later, Sandra received the news no family wants to hear.

Ultimately, the torso found in the river was Alexandra.

Her head, arms, and legs were removed from her body. There had been weights in addition to the chains from her neck to her upper legs. To this day, her head, arms, and legs have not been found.

13 year old Alexandra Anaya was murdered in 2005 | Momma Loves True Crime

The Main Suspect in the Murder of Alexandra

Although the police say that everyone is a suspect, they feel that Alexandra knew her killer.

Her family had many issues with her mother's former boyfriend, Rudolfo Heredia, whom Sandra had twins with.Alex's torso was found 5 blocks from Heredia's home.

In September 2005, police were holding Herdia. The US Attorney's office filed interstate domestic violence charges. After his arrest, Heredia admitted to making a duplicate key to the Anaya family home. As well as watching the family while they were at home.

The FBI also learned from Sandra Anaya that Heredia had been molesting Alexandra. This abuse began when she was around 7 years old. She also told them that he had been violent with her.

When she broke up with him, he threatened to kill her.

In December of 2005, additional charges of "residential burglary and placing the Hammond woman in reasonable fear of death or serious bodily injury".

Consequently, he was acquitted.

No charges have ever been filed in relation to Alexandra's murder.

13 year old Alexandra Anaya was murdered in 2005 | Momma Loves True Crime

Case Gone Cold

In 2016, the FBI began pursuing new leads. Even retesting some items for DNA evidence. With advancements in forensics, this may lead to new information. To this day, the case is very much active.

No other suspect has been publicly named.

However, Sandra Anaya feels that she knows who killed her daughter. On the other hand, there is not enough evidence to prove it.

In short, someone out there knows something.

If you have information regarding the murder of Alexandra Anaya, call the FBI Chicago Field Office at 312-421-6700.


NBC Chicago Article August 2016

Chicago Tribune Article August 2016

The Times of Northwest Indiana


Most Visited Cases

The Disappearance of Jaliek Rainwalker

The Disappearance of Brookelyn Farthing

The Disappearance of Heather Teague

The Murder of Fiona Yu

The Disappearance of Andrea Knabel